“This is just spiffing” enthused Minister of Popular Culture Ed Vaizey speaking at Tuesday’s 800-strong fossil hunting rally at Wrens Nest National Nature Reserve, Dudley.
“Hail to Britain’s heroic band of amateur palaeontologists! I had a go myself and found a belemnite. Imagine, I was the first person to hold it in my hand since the original owner dropped it all those thousands of years ago.”
“Ed’s right” commented rally organiser Wayne “Findgobbler” Proley of the Dudley and District Community Fossil Recovery Service, speaking from inside his one-man tent….
“It’s been a fantastic day. We’re doing no harm and it’s legal, is it not old bean? We’ve had people come from far and wide, across the sea and that – they have evil governments in that place that won’t allow it so them being free to get diggy at a place like Wren’s Nest in the daytime is a unique experience for them. Makes me proud to be British.
And every single one of them is in it for the love of palaeontology, nothing else. EBay’s a liar. DEFRA (the Department for Everyman’s Full Right to ‘Ave stuff) tried to stop the event as they said there was nationally important stuff here but we countered them neatly by saying “We know that yer goody two shoos, why’d you think we targeted it, so we wouldn’t find nothing? Duh! (They’ll never get the better of us in verbal jowsting).”
Despite DEFRA’s misgivings the event was attended by palaeontologists from the Portable Fossil Scheme. “It’s been marvellous” enthused one of the Scheme’s Finds Liason Officers, Tarquin Toffman…
“The fossils are all just sitting there, some out of context and some not, so it’s harmless except where it isn’t. It’s a real privilege to see an unknown percentage of an unknown number of items being shown to us and of course it’s thrilling to interact with all these fine chaps, we have so much in common, all of us being interested in the past and having two legs. I’ve slapped so many backs I’ve got patronisers’ elbow. Fossil hunting is a Good Thing it says here on my payslip.”
After a couple of threatening official phone calls from a mysterious”Friend” DEFRA issued a revised statement on the event:
“We’ve pulled out all the stops to get this event off the ground (to repeat verbatim what we said on a previous occasion). The way it was designed originally it would have been unspeakably destructive but we’ve negotiated with Findgobbler whereby he and his friends will now do exactly what they want not what we want so the event now only registers as EO (Effing Outrageous) on the Civilised Behaviour scale of the various conservation conventions that Britain has inadvertently forgotten to ratify. It just goes to show, jaw-jaw is better than war-war – and craven submission is even simpler.”
English Heritage, who have made not stepping on the Portable Fossil Scheme’s toes into an art form, said a visit to Warwick Castle is a super day out.
17 comments
Comments feed for this article
20/05/2012 at 12:34
Gemma Woodcroft
I dont understand?. Was there really a fossil hunting rally?
20/05/2012 at 13:26
heritageaction
Hi Gemma,
Sorry for not making it clear, no there wasn’t, and if there was it would be seen as an international scandal. But there ARE metal detecting rallies, dozens of them. The article was our way of highlighting how unacceptable they are regarded as almost everywhere except Britain.
20/05/2012 at 14:02
Gemma Woodcroft
Not so sure its a good comparison. I take my children fossil hunting at Chesil beach and they love it and it gives them an interest to develop. Not so sure i like them now deemed as vandals. What drove you to write the article?
20/05/2012 at 16:23
heritageaction
It wasn’t about Chesil Beach it was about Wren’s Nest, which is a National Nature Reserve and a place where an 8oo person fossil rally would be regarded as unthinkable and dreadful – yet artefact hunting rallies of up to 2,000 people on archaeologically sensitive sites are both legal and officially sanctioned.
20/05/2012 at 17:40
Gemma
It is a very poorly executed article then. So it is OK to search for fossils at Chesil beach?
I found this on the Wrens Nest site re code of practise.
The children of Bramford Wildlife Group
ask that you –
• Don’t use hammers anywhere on the
reserve
• Don’t ride motorbikes, light fires, drop litter,
or make camps and rope swings
• Take only two or three small fossils that are already
loose on the ground away with you
• Do not climb on or damage the rock faces
• Stay on footpaths and do not enter safety fenced areas
• Do not throw your fossils away when you have finished with them!
Donate them to your local museum.
These two points below are of note;
X – Take only two or three small fossils that are already
loose on the ground away with you
X – Do not throw your fossils away when you have finished with them!
Donate them to your local museum.
So people can collect fossils there!!.
I never knew of this place until now, but we must visit it next time we are up in the midlands. Looks very interesting.
Thanks for the info
20/05/2012 at 18:38
Paul Barford
Gemma, the comparison is not so far off, Chesil Beach is a SSSI as well as part of the UNESCO World Heritage List sites. “Take nothing except photos” might be the responsible thing to teach the kids at places like that. Surely how to treat special places is exactly what this is all about.
20/05/2012 at 18:46
Tom Berry
And just were do you get this alarmist figure of 2,000 people attending a metal metal detecting rally from?. A quick Google of only shows the Heritage Journal mentioning such a rally, no one else does. Let’s do the basic maths here guys. 2,000 people at a metal detecting rally would represent 1 in 5 of the UK’s metal detectorists all gathered together at the same time- It won’t ever happen in any sport/hobby/discipline EVER.
Secondly, even if by some miracle you did gather 2,000 metal detectorists together, how much land would they need to search?. Hmmm, at one acre a piece, that would require 2,000 acres wouldn’t it?.That’s the size of a Scottish highland country estate, not UK farmland. Besides, one acre is not enough to keep a metal detectorist busy for more than an hour or two and certainly not enough to entice 1 in 5 of all UK metal detectorists to attend. They may as well search their back gardens. So lets say they each have a conservative 10 acres to detect ( that is 15 football pitches) then the rally would be held over 20,000 acres – this is the size of the city of Belfast BTW !
Far from defending metal detecting, i am just defending the truth as this alarmist figure of 2,000 people at a Metal Detecting rally is really insulting my and other journal readers intelligence.
It’s a good journal but drop the alarmist element to preserve credibility please, Many a worthy cause has been lost because of this.
Tom
PS, prove me wrong about 2,000 people attending a UK metal detecting rally and that it is commonplace!!
20/05/2012 at 19:41
heritageaction
Tom, our figure of 2,000 people that you feel insults your intelligence was taken direct from British Archaeology magazine. Having attended it and tried to calculate the number I’m confident that was about right.
20/05/2012 at 19:57
Tom Berry
So you take it as a given as it came from British Archaeology Magazine?. And you then attended it and ‘Tried’ to calculate the numbers atrending but it seems you drew no conclusive proof. So what was this mysterious Rally then? Do you or do you not dispute my rationale as to how the numbers are ridiculous? Do you?.
Please tell us more about this Rally such as when and where and any details on the web. Was it a ‘one off’ event?
I am now even more puzzled and am looking forward to the answer as i’m sure are others.
20/05/2012 at 20:33
heritageaction
Well, since you’re clearly disinclined to accept the account of either me or BA magazine I’m disinclined to oblige you further. However, the event was extremely well known and well documented and you can contact Mike Pitts at BA or any of the PAS team that was there, I’m sure they’ll be delighted to help. Good luck.
20/05/2012 at 20:46
Paul Barford
were the PAS there? Did any of the FLOs have a go at metal detecting?
20/05/2012 at 20:57
heritageaction
Ha! I’d love to see the wording of the FLO manual on that subject!
“Try to like them but don’t try to BE like them”?
😉
21/05/2012 at 08:57
Gerd
Are there fossil collecting rallies in UK?.
21/05/2012 at 09:34
heritageaction
Not that I know of. Although, in a country where people can make a lot of money by deliberately holding a single metal detecting rally on an archaeological site and the law allows them to, who knows if the same winning formula for making money will soon be applied to fossils? Bear in mind detecting rallies of the size of our imaginary fossil rally, involving 800 people over several days, can gross more than £20,000. Better than working as a Conservation Officer!
22/05/2012 at 07:46
George
One cannot help but be reminded of the antiquarians of old and where might this lead to in the long term? Perhaps Fossil collecting should be more regulated than it is now (i’m not even sure it is regualted at all).
24/05/2012 at 19:54
Proximo
Are there such things as fossil collecting clubs, like there are metal detecting clubs?
25/05/2012 at 05:57
heritageaction
It seems so, although we’re not experts on them. They do seem to be against collecting from untouched cliffs along the Jurassic Coast, for instance, whereas the whole purpose of metal detecting is to seek out and exploit “hot spots” i.e. archaeological sites, so there’s quite a difference in attitudes.